How To Judge The Quality Of A Coffee Shop

How To Judge The Quality Of A Coffee Shop

Stepping into a coffee shop for the first time is an exciting adventure for coffee enthusiasts.

We all crave that perfect cup of java that not only satisfies our taste buds but also reflects the skill and dedication of the baristas behind the counter. However, it's easy for coffee shops to conceal the true quality of their beans with fancy specialty drinks that deviate from the essence of coffee itself. Fear not, as we embark on a journey to unravel the secrets of a truly exceptional coffee shop experience.


When venturing into uncharted coffee territory, it's essential to select the right beverages to ensure you're getting a well-crafted brew made from top-notch beans. By choosing wisely, you'll gain insights into the shop's operation and the dedication they have towards their coffee.


The first step in assessing a coffee shop is to keep a watchful eye on the baristas as they prepare your drink. Through their techniques and attentiveness, you can discern their commitment to delivering a superb cup of coffee. Whether it's an espresso shot or a meticulous pour-over, observing their craft provides valuable information about the shop's overall quality.


While the ubiquitous Starbucks and other chain coffee shops offer convenience, their staff often lacks extensive training in the art of coffee-making. Therefore, if you're seeking an extraordinary experience, it's advisable to explore local establishments where baristas undergo specialized training and possess the necessary skills to excel in their craft. Look for four fundamental skills that a well-trained barista should possess.

  1. Mastering the art of grinding and brewing drip coffee.
  2. Expertly crafting pour-over and French press coffee.
  3. Creating exquisite espresso-based beverages such as lattes, cortados, and cappuccinos.
  4. Calibrating and pulling espressos for specialty drinks.


Every coffee shop has its own area of expertise. Some may excel in producing exceptional espressos, while others may boast remarkable pour-overs. To fully appreciate the shop's prowess, it's recommended to order a drink that aligns with their specialty. By doing so, you not only give them an opportunity to shine but also increase your chances of being impressed.


Espresso, with its intense flavors, can be a challenging beverage to master. A poorly brewed shot can result in an unpleasantly sour taste. Currently, the trend leans toward lighter roasted beans, known for their bright flavors. However, it's crucial to note that brewing them incorrectly can lead to a puckering experience. Ordering an espresso provides an opportunity to explore different taste profiles and identify your personal preference. When ordering, pay attention to a few crucial aspects:

  • Ensure the espresso is properly dosed, as indicated by the use of a scale.
  • Check the bean hopper for cleanliness to avoid any residual coffee oils.
  • Savor your espresso while it's piping hot and freshly brewed to fully appreciate its flavors and aroma.


If you're a globetrotter, it's fascinating to note the variations in espresso brewing methods across different countries. In Italy, a traditional espresso is brewed at a 1:3 ratio of coffee to water, yielding a less potent shot. In contrast, the United States follows a 1:1 to 1:2 ratio, resulting in a stronger brew. Keep this in mind when exploring various espresso options during your travels.


Pour-over coffee is an excellent gauge of a coffee shop's quality, but only if it's listed on their menu. Avoid ordering a pour-over as a means to assess a shop that doesn't offer it, as it may lead to disappointment. A well-executed pour-over should take approximately three minutes. If it takes longer, the beans might be ground too fine, while a shorter time may indicate excessively coarse grounds. A perfectly crafted pour-over showcases the barista's skills and provides a delightful and flavorful experience. It's also an opportunity to taste the beans in their purest form.


When evaluating a coffee shop's ability to deliver exceptional espresso drinks, high-quality beans, and skilled baristas, the cortado reigns supreme. This exquisite beverage requires a delicate balance of steamed milk and espresso, allowing the flavors of the beans to shine through. A well-made cortado signifies the barista's proficiency in milk texturing, portioning, and espresso extraction. Remember, a true cortado follows a 1:1 ratio of espresso to steamed milk, without variations based on size.

As coffee enthusiasts, we all have our personal preferences when it comes to ordering our favorite brew. When exploring new coffee shops, choosing the right beverages from our guide can help you evaluate the establishment's commitment to quality and refine your palate. Ultimately, finding a coffee shop that resonates with you is a journey worth embarking on. So keep exploring, savoring, and discovering the joy of a perfectly brewed cup of coffee in your quest for the ultimate coffee shop experience.

Back to blog